Terry Theise notes “By now you know this singular estate has been holding certain wines back, in cask and without sulfur, until they are deemed ready to bottle. There have been Rieslings (the supernal 1990) and GrüVes (the amazing ‘91), and now this. The 1993 in the glass was bottled in early April 2008, directly from the cask in which it lay since fermentation. It begins by tasting woody, and then becomes roasty and protein-y and fatty, like the cracklings of a suckling-pig roast. It then gets leafy and the teensiest bit root-y, like celeriac; a full year in bottle has actually made it fresher and fruitier, albeit with its Jurasienne touch. (If it were Jura it would be the best wine ever made there.) The secret-sweetness and the woodsy patina are just ravishing. It’s settled into its new home and has started to glow.I asked if there was a candidate for the next Vinothek bottling. “Actually there are several,” they replied. “But we want to surprise you.” Good: I like surprises.”Nikolaihof Gruner Veltliner Weinberge Smaragd 1999 ($149.95) $119 special 1 bottle left
Nikolaihof Gruner Veltliner Weinberge Smaragd 2010 ($69.95) $59 special 7 bottles left
Terry Theise notes “Their non-vinificationvinification removes all trace of severity from 2010; it’s like a complex deciduous forest on a warm rainy day, the scent of the leaves and the dripping bark. The finish is haunting and poetic. It’s deep and sweet and will be amazingly complex in 4-6 years.I should emphasize, I don’t need to or want to summon any kind of spell when I’m tasting here. I try instead to erase my screen and then transcribe whatever takes place. I mean, the wines are how they are, and I seem to feel my only authentic response is directly into image and metaphor. And the tasting itself is quite workmanlike; 4-5 glasses are lined up and the wines poured into flights, just like anywhere else. And then they start to peal, and the usual deconstruction of flavors just isn’t called for. Better to fall into the aura of the pealing, to hear the complicated overtones, to feel the air between the wine and me. That’s what seems to work. + +”
Nikolaihof Gruner Veltliner Weingebirge Smaragd 2011 ($64.95) $55 special 12 bottles left
Terry Theise notes “Delicate and soulful. Not a flashy first impression. 12.6% alc. Pea shoot and vetiver and a curious tickle of tannin; a careful beautiful wine with nothing to prove. Again a stirringly mineral finish.I should emphasize, I don’t need to or want to summon any kind of spell when I’m tasting here. I try instead to erase my screen and then transcribe whatever takes place. I mean, the wines are how they are, and I seem to feel my only authentic response is directly into image and metaphor. And the tasting itself is quite workmanlike; 4-5 glasses are lined up and the wines poured into flights, just like anywhere else. And then they start to peal, and the usual deconstruction of flavors just isn’t called for. Better to fall into the aura of the pealing, to hear the complicated overtones, to feel the air between the wine and me. That’s what seems to work.”
Nikolaihof Gruner Veltliner Weingebirge Federspiel 2012 ($34.94)
$27 special 22 bottles left
Terry Theise notes “Markedly lissome and chiseled, slate-blue eyes and high cheekbones; even a little phenolic and certainly mineral, especially for this estate. The finish is clipped but the alc is below 12%, and the clarity and oyster grip is almost more typical for Hefeabzug.”
Nikolaihof Riesling Vinothek Wachau 1995 ($179.95) $149 special 2+ cases left
Terry Theise notes “It’s just 12.5% alcohol. This tender wine has been alone so long, it’s almost forgotten how to speak in language—so it sings. All it does is sing. You want to speak of its noble oxidation but you get caught in the sultry web of its amazing floweriness and pure vetiver. It actually, after all these years in cask, needs oxygen. Your sensual-analytical skills don’t help you here. Put them away. Quiet down, all the way down. You can enter the house, they’ve left the door unlocked. But once inside, the rooms are dim. You find your way by an instinct you didn’t know you had. You listen as you never did before. And you are given back to yourself, a strange new person, swimming in beauty and as supple as a child, pensive
and amazed.”
Nikolaihof Riesling Steinriesler 1998 ($84.95) $69 special 14 bottles left
Terry Theise notes “Riesler” is an archaic term for Riesling. Saahs wanted to see how a wine might age in cask without sulfur if it were an ordinary and not a grand wine to begin with. The first example was a glorious 1999, offered two years ago. So what do they do for an encore? Offer something even older. This is a masterpiece of time, nature and instinct. Less “humble” than that ‘99 was, and more insanely, dauntingly complex. I could detail its three paragraphs worth of nuance if I had 40 minutes to study it. Let’s just say, a perfect positive oxidation, a whole encyclopedia of wild flowers and herbs, a mélange of every possible salt, and the gentlest note of allspice and pink peppercorn.”
Nikolaihof Riesling Weingebirge Jungfernlese 1999 ($109.95) $89 special 5 bottles left
Nikolaihof Riesling Vom Stein Jungfernlese 2006 ($59.95) $49 special 2 cases left
Terry Theise notes “It means the virgin-vintage, the first crop from young vines. And it’s what the Germans would call Feinherb, and it’s what any sane person would call irresistible! A potion of iris and lavender, spicy and penetrating; very long, seductively earthy, like a really profound Nahe Spätlese, almost the 5-spice and wildflower of Dönnhoff’s Felsenberg.”
Nikolaihof Riesling Steiner Hund Reserve 2008 ($79.95) $66 special 18 bottles left
Terry Theise notes “This vineyard is existentially unique, as if it had its own magnetic fields. Druids would have built their megaliths there. Maybe at night a UFO lands silently and all the little space dudes get out and do some magic, I don’t know. But I know of no other great wine that seems so unknowable, overwhelming and haunting. For a Nikolaihof ‘08 this is markedly ripe (13%), and it shows a lot of counterpoint between its druidic exotics and Chartreuse-y herbalness, versus its jasmine and white chocolate yang side. Potentially great, it’s still busy working through its contradictions. The implosion of minerality may eventually mediate among them. A superb and complicated Riesling. + +”
Nikolaihof Riesling Vom Stein Smaragd 2009 ($69.95) $59 special 12 bottles left
Terry Theise notes “As ‘09 is, this shows chamomile and beeswax, but as ‘09 rarely is, this is taut and grippy, and maybe still too young. There’s a grassy herbal currant-leaf mid-palate, and the wine almost visibly picks up steam in the glass. Still, it’s a shy kind of critter for this estate. (+)”
Nikolaihof Riesling Steiner Hund Reserve 2009 ($69.95) $59 special 2 bottles left
Terry Theise notes “This vineyard is existentially unique, as if it had its own magnetic fields. Druids would have built their megaliths there.Maybe at night a UFO lands silently and all the little space dudes get out and do some magic, I don’t know. But I knowof no other great wine that seems so unknowable, overwhelming and haunting. Beautiful and unusual, all of its gorgeously strange green mineral together with the chamomile and yellow fruits and osmanthus of ’09! I mean really, you can’t stop sniffing it. More solid and firmly spicy than the more oxidative ’08 and ’07; this is like the ’05 diving into an ice cold pool; all the crazy mineral jazz plays on the back palate.”
Nikolaihof Riesling Vom Stein Smaragd 2010 750ml ($64.95) $55 special 12 bottles left
Nikolaihof Riesling Vom Stein Smaragd 2010 1.5L ($139.95) $119 special 6 bottles left
Terry Theise notes “Almost rugged and gnarly-that’s ’10 baby. Flowering fields aroma doesn’t specifically signal “Riesling,” but the stretchy sinewy palate scratches that very itch; it’s the sting of mint without the mint of mint.”
Terry Theise notes ” Adorable aromas of quince and currant leaf lead into a lively spicy fennel-y palate. The direct attack is really, ah, striking. Though they didn’t design it, of course. It’s like tatsoi leaves you eat from the bag.”